An analysis of herodotus account of the battle of thermopylae

an analysis of herodotus account of the battle of thermopylae Thermopylae, after the fashion of thyrea, was a contest that tested the national character of both sparta and persia it was a battle that herodotus tried to show the spartans actually won and as proof of the spartans' victory, the true outcome of the battle was in a sense ratified by the refighting of the contest at the battle of plataea.

Analysis of herodotus: book seven the actions of the spartans in the battle show that herodotus is true in this respect memorial at thermopylae. Workbook and answer key herodotus 4: the battle of thermopylae herodotus 5: the battle of salamis,. Simonides, ephorus, and herodotus on the battle of thermopylae probably made some use of herodotus for his own account of the persian wars.

The histories also stands as one of the first accounts at the beginning of the histories, herodotus (~5,283,220 (herodotus) ) the battle of thermopylae in. 93803 herodotu—herodotus (2008) the history: an account of the persian war on greece st battle of thermopylae history press cd 93803 cartledg. The thermopylae 'myth': ancient and modern attitudes to the battle context of the battle herodotus' account of aristodemos would have only confirmed to readers. On the battle of thermopylae itself, two principal sources, herodotus and simonides, survive herodotus' account of the battle, in book vii of his histories , is such an important source that paul cartledge writes that we either write a history of thermopylae with [herodotus], or not at all [15.

The battle of thermopylae from herodotus research assignment (essay sample) battle of thermopylae from herodotus historian who gave an account of the battle. The main source that described the battle of thermopylae is the book vii of herodotus he was a greek historian, and in his book he generally favors the greeks but he also writes about the greatness of the persian empire. Primary sources for battle of thermopylae create an account 1 in herodotus, leonidas gets killed, the remaining greeks form a shieldwall on a hillock, and. In this scene drawn from the account in herodotus, croesus shows off his the histories lesson 5 herodotus iv: battle of thermopylae leonidas at thermopylae. Criticism of herodotus' work seems to have originated among athenians who took exception to his account of the battle of marathon (490 bce) and, specifically, which families were due the most honor for the victory over the persians more serious criticism of his work has to do with the credibility of the accounts of his travels.

Irrespective of herodotus, the later author ktesiy from knid told about the battle of thermopylae, according to the persian sources (green 115) probably, ktesiy's work was used by diodor in his description of the 300 spartans` feat. Some modern accounts seem to know exactly on what dates the battle fell, because herodotus says (7 206) the the festival of apollo carneia was on at sparta and that. The battle of thermopylae, the pass at thermopylae was thus opened to the persian army according to herodotus, at the cost to the persians of up to 20,000.

The battle of thermopylae: herodotus vs the movie '300' this famous battle between a few spartans and the persian army has been told and re-told by many people through the ages, with differing accounts of the terrain, tactics and size of the opposing armies. The battle of thermopylae, which herodotus recorded in his writing the histories, was one of the most arduous and notable battles of western history herodotus was an extremely significant historian who lived during the 5th century bc. The battle of thermopylae, which herodotus recorded in his writing the histories, was one of the most arduous and notable battles of western history - the battle of thermopylae from herodotus' the histories introduction.

The battle of thermopylae in the 2007 film 300 photograph: allstar herodotus is the most entertaining of historians indeed, he is as entertaining as anyone who has ever written, historian or not. Rudy mate's interpretation of the battle of thermopylae in the 300 spartans incorporates themes which are expressed continuously throughout herodotus' the histories herodotus highlights the alliance of the greek city-states during the persian wars, also discussing the disunity and betrayal amongst the greeks. 300: the battle at thermopylae we are aware of the battle because of the works of the greek historian herodotus (circa 484 bc - circa 425 bc),. Herodotus c484 bc-c herodotus is best known for his long and compelling prose account of it is about the famous battle of thermopylae that mainly involved.

Though herodotus' account came from a date that was closer to the actual battle of thermopylae, the number of men he claims were present and their allegiances is inconsistent with the reports of other historians. 1) as herodotus wasn't a actual witness to the battle but the battle was contemporary to his life and his writings reflect the observations of a person living with the perspective of the victors his account is biased by the virtue that he belonged to the society that had been victorious. Thermopylae was a hugely important battle because of its military tactics during this battle, the greeks used the narrow path called the middle gate as a defense to make the persian army's greater numbers meaningless the persian army, led by xerxes, had 25 million soldiers, according to the. The account of the battle of thermopylae found in diodorus siculus (1184-104) is remarkably different from the more commonly known herodotean version of events (7201-33) most strikingly, his account includes details of a night raid on the persian camp made by leonidas and his men.

an analysis of herodotus account of the battle of thermopylae Thermopylae, after the fashion of thyrea, was a contest that tested the national character of both sparta and persia it was a battle that herodotus tried to show the spartans actually won and as proof of the spartans' victory, the true outcome of the battle was in a sense ratified by the refighting of the contest at the battle of plataea. an analysis of herodotus account of the battle of thermopylae Thermopylae, after the fashion of thyrea, was a contest that tested the national character of both sparta and persia it was a battle that herodotus tried to show the spartans actually won and as proof of the spartans' victory, the true outcome of the battle was in a sense ratified by the refighting of the contest at the battle of plataea. an analysis of herodotus account of the battle of thermopylae Thermopylae, after the fashion of thyrea, was a contest that tested the national character of both sparta and persia it was a battle that herodotus tried to show the spartans actually won and as proof of the spartans' victory, the true outcome of the battle was in a sense ratified by the refighting of the contest at the battle of plataea.
An analysis of herodotus account of the battle of thermopylae
Rated 3/5 based on 48 review

2018.